• About
  • Support AJW
  • Jewish Community Directory
  • Subscription Information
  • Contact Us
American Jewish World
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    One of Minnesota’s most accomplished  women, Geri Joseph, dies at 100

    One of Minnesota’s most accomplished women, Geri Joseph, dies at 100

    Editorial: A visit to Denmark and Sweden — and war breaks out

    Editorial: A visit to Denmark and Sweden — and war breaks out

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    I.B. Singer’s American essays

    I.B. Singer’s American essays

    When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

    When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

    Les Block, our music maven

    Les Block, our music maven

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Robyn Frank finds her niche in the cookie business

    Robyn Frank finds her niche in the cookie business

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    One of Minnesota’s most accomplished  women, Geri Joseph, dies at 100

    One of Minnesota’s most accomplished women, Geri Joseph, dies at 100

    Editorial: A visit to Denmark and Sweden — and war breaks out

    Editorial: A visit to Denmark and Sweden — and war breaks out

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    I.B. Singer’s American essays

    I.B. Singer’s American essays

    When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

    When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

    Les Block, our music maven

    Les Block, our music maven

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

    Robyn Frank finds her niche in the cookie business

    Robyn Frank finds her niche in the cookie business

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
Home Arts

Saving Israel from itself

‘The Crisis of Zionism’, by Peter Beinart, Times Books, 304 pages, $26

American Jewish World by American Jewish World
May 23, 2020
in Arts, Books & Literature
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Reviewed by NEAL GENDLER

J Street supporters probably will like Peter Beinart’s The Crisis of Zionism a lot.

READ ALSO

I.B. Singer’s American essays

When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

The rest of us maybe not so much. But it’s thoughtful and important, and I found myself agreeing with many of its main points. Israel-bashers will lament that Beinart wholly supports the Jewish state.

But he thinks that it’s moving too far from its founding ideals and that the American Jewish establishment is abetting that drift.

Beinart argues that the occupation is destroying Israeli democracy and diminishing support among younger American Jews; that the American Jewish establishment has “lurched right,” its leading organizations abandoning Jewish liberalism and becoming increasingly unrepresentative of the Jewish majority, and that American Jews should feel freer to criticize Israel.

He opposes criticism of Israel’s legitimacy but says the occupation is morally wrong, creating two Israels — one democratic and one not.

Peter Beinart (Photo: Guillaume Gaudet)
Peter Beinart (Photo: Guillaume Gaudet)

Crisis, said to be controversial, is surprisingly balanced and non-strident. Beinart, no member of Blame Israel First, proclaims himself a Zionist, sends his son to a Jewish school and davens in a Modern Orthodox shul. He sees Israel’s virtues as well as its faults, mainly its treatment of Arabs in Israel and in the territories. He mostly acknowledges those faults’ origins, meaning that Arabs share blame.

Beinart’s beautifully written introduction is brilliant, observing that American Jews haven’t internalized the enormous change from their powerlessness and from anti-Semitism, and that Jews under 44 never knew a time when Israel didn’t control Judea and Samaria. But he argues that Israel is failing as a democracy because of its rule over its Palestinian Arab “subjects.”

A big problem, he says, is that “young American Jews are far less likely [than their elders] to build their identity around victimhood.” Many have scant Jewish education, reducing Jewish involvement and love for the Jewish state. Regarding Israel less as a refuge than as a distant, imperfect democracy, they’re “abandoning American Zionism.”

He says young Modern Orthodox are strongly committed to Israel but less so to Israeli democracy, calling theirs “illiberal Zionism.” Beinart says Birthright Israel, which gives young Jews a free 10-day trip to the Jewish state, is too new to judge its long-term effects.

With subtle but impressive care for balance and accuracy, Beinart refers to “the lines that prevailed before the 1967 six-day war”; even Jews, unthinkingly and incorrectly, call those 1949 armistice lines “borders.”

Beinart shows less concern about map lines than that “occupying another people requires racism, and breeds it.” This is a failure of Israeli democracy, “and American Jews are helping it fail… Unless American Jews help end the occupation that desecrates Israel’s founding ideals,” he says, Zionism will become “a movement that fails the test of Jewish power.”

Well! Beinart makes a strong political and moral case against continued rule over Judea and Samaria. (He says Jerusalem and the Golan are different because Arabs there can become Israeli citizens.) But despite the need for the majority of non-Orthodox American Jews to remain committed to Israel — which he ably argues requires Israel to remain a liberal democracy — he is not convincing when arguing that Israel should make security decisions based on how American Jews will react.

Life-and-death decisions belong to those who share the risks and consequences, and Beinart and we American Jews live an ocean away — not in Sderot. And, with rare exceptions, we do not send our children to guard Israel’s borders.

Beinart leaves plenty for readers to consider. He says the Netanyahu government is trying to prevent a Palestinian Arab state by creating conditions that make it impossible for the Arabs to settle. But for the first nine months of Obama’s 10-month “settlement freeze,” the Palestinian Authority refused to negotiate.

Negotiation means compromise; I don’t recall an official P.A. statement offering to settle for anything less than maximal demands — which it must know are beyond the Israeli consensus. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s last offer to P.A. President Mahmoud Abbas — which reportedly included great concessions — went unanswered, according to an article in the April 9 edition of the mostly liberal Jerusalem Report magazine.

(One cannot help asking: Are there any terms to which the Arabs would agree for an end to hostilities and a final settlement?)

Beinart’s idea that by freely criticizing Israel, American Jews will alter its behavior and thus feel more attached to it doesn’t seem to consider that free speech isn’t free of negative, as well as positive, consequences. When Jews claiming to love Israel criticize it publicly, no one hears love, only criticism — as already has happened with his book and newspaper accounts.

Public opinion drives our government’s policies. If Jews don’t appear to support Israel, why should anyone else?

***

Neal Gendler is a Minneapolis writer and editor.

(American Jewish World, 4.13.12)

Related Posts

I.B. Singer’s American essays
Books & Literature

I.B. Singer’s American essays

December 3, 2023
When Israel was attacked 50 years ago
Books & Literature

When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

November 9, 2023
Les Block, our music maven
Minnesota

Les Block, our music maven

August 8, 2023
Journey to the old land of woe
Books & Literature

Journey to the old land of woe

August 7, 2023
Jews bring the funny to the Fringe
Theater & Performing Arts

Jews bring the funny to the Fringe

August 7, 2023
Repressing memories of a week in 1970
Books & Literature

Repressing memories of a week in 1970

July 23, 2023
Next Post

The Last Word tops MJTC season

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECENT ARTICLES

I.B. Singer’s American essays

I.B. Singer’s American essays

December 3, 2023
Tracing family roots in Germany

Tracing family roots in Germany

December 3, 2023
Two op-eds display a widening schism over Israel

Two op-eds display a widening schism over Israel

December 4, 2023
Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

Kids, enter the AJW Hanuka Cover Contest!

November 10, 2023
When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

When Israel was attacked 50 years ago

November 9, 2023

About

Since 1912 the AJW has served as an important news resource for the Jewish community. The Jewish World unites the main Jewish communities in St. Paul and Minneapolis, as well as those in Duluth, Rochester and smaller cities, and bridges the divides between the various Jewish religious streams.

Quick Links

  • About the AJW
  • Advertising Information
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Subscription Information
  • Jewish Community Directory

Contact Us

The American Jewish World
3249 Hennepin Ave., Suite 245
Minneapolis, MN 55408

Tel: 612.824.0030 / Fax: 612.823.0753
editor@ajwnews.com

  • Buy JNews
  • Landing Page
  • Documentation
  • Support Forum

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Homepages
    • Home Page 1
  • News
  • Food
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.