• About
  • Jewish Community Directory
  • Subscription Information
  • Contact Us
American Jewish World
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    Jews and the Civil Rights Movement in Minnesota

    Jews and the Civil Rights Movement in Minnesota

    Hopkins, Minneapolis schools to take off for High Holy Days

    Hopkins, Minneapolis schools to take off for High Holy Days

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    ‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

    ‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    Jews and the Civil Rights Movement in Minnesota

    Jews and the Civil Rights Movement in Minnesota

    Hopkins, Minneapolis schools to take off for High Holy Days

    Hopkins, Minneapolis schools to take off for High Holy Days

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    ‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

    ‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
Home Arts Books & Literature

What’s the right basis of living?

'Judaism Straight Up: Why Real Religion Endures,' by Moshe Koppel, Maggid, 195 pages, $24.95

mordecai by mordecai
March 12, 2021
in Arts, Books & Literature, Featured
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Reviewed by NEAL GENDLER

Moshe Koppel makes a provocative argument for the societal value of religion and religious communities, even if his prediction of societal doom for abandoning them includes some assumptions open to argument.

READ ALSO

Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

He illustrates Judaism Straight Up with two Jews several decades apart, calling them Shimen and Heidi. They disagree on the right basis for living.

When Koppel met Heidi, she was a Princeton humanities grad student who’d “taken it upon herself to educate me about the special duties of the Jewish people to humanity.”

She asked him how he could justify his “narrow parochial tribal loyalty.” Didn’t the Shoah teach Jews never to put their “parochial interests ahead of others’ interests?”

Shoah survivor Shimen was Koppel’s grandfather’s best friend among the Gerer Hasidim with whom he prayed. Their Manhattan shtiebel (prayer room) “had the look and feel of the hundreds… that dotted Poland before every one of them was destroyed.”

Members retained loyalty to their prewar ways, absent the beards and fur hats. “They were God-fearing Jews, but they felt sufficiently at home with God to take liberties as necessary,” Koppel says.

The Heidi types Koppel has known “patronize old Shimens as addle-brained relics out of touch with contemporary doctrines.”

But Koppel, a computer science professor at Bar-Ilan University, sees the world through their eyes: “My views are hopelessly, and proudly, old fashioned.” Some seem to veer into the terrain of right-wing politics. (Examples: “social costs of government handouts” and of laws about recycling.)

Straight Up focuses on “three main differences” between Shimen’s and Heidi’s worlds. The first is “the scope of morality.” Heidi, raised in a kosher-at-home milieu that she has discarded, focuses on fairness.

Shimen feels morally bound to the Jewish people in a world where choices “all are fraught with moral considerations” but are second nature, requiring little thought. For matters that do, Shimen can turn to Jewish texts, even a rabbi.

The second difference “concerns the mechanisms through which communities determine the boundaries of the forbidden and the obligatory.”

Heidi’s relevant community is the citizenry. Obligations and prohibitions are determined by public policy and enforced by prosecution. Shimen’s community is “those committed to the norms of the Jewish way of life,” halacha, with norms determined by tradition and enforced by social pressure.

“The third difference concerns the relationship of one’s beliefs about the world to one’s social and moral commitments.” Heidi’s commitments come from studying science and history; Shimen’s come from his religious beliefs.

Koppel finds that Shimen’s ways fulfill the societally necessary principles of fairness, loyalty and restraint and that Heidi’s, minimizing loyalty and restraint, lead to social doom.

Heidi wants the state to create and enforce policies promoting public welfare and equality but without involving or enforcing restraint and loyalty. Shimen wants “the meaning and purpose that he gets from participating in the ongoing project of the Jews.”

Heidi wants freedom from such projects. For her, canonical beliefs have no credibility or appeal.

We don’t know the extent to which these views are theirs or Koppel’s assumptions. But there is some truth in each of these characters.

Heidi’s nontraditional world lacks Shimen’s system of rich and detailed social norms and communal institutions that promote his community’s “interdependence, voluntary compliance and social capital,” Koppel says.

Heidi uses the state to fill the gap — “the wrong venue for achieving Heidi’s goals,” Koppel says.

“Bereft of tradition, individuals can’t simply reason their way to rules that encourage virtue” or create “a strong sense of common purpose,” he says. “Individual autonomy is reduced to mere self-indulgence and self-centeredness. Social capital diminishes and social bonds fray,” increasing need to “rein in people through powerful institutions,” he says.

Apparently that would be government, but cooperation for social equilibrium requires not only fairness but also deferral of pleasure and expressions of group solidarity, qualities sometimes in tension, he says.

Koppel has a thoughtful and interesting take on the roots of Judeophobia and on young Israelis’ growing interest in Judaism as a national culture.

Straight Up is crammed with insightful observations, plus good, witty writing. It’s worthwhile reading, requiring thought, even when disagreeing.

Fortunately, Koppel’s argument for religious tradition doesn’t criticize non-Orthodox movements, only the notion that Jewish tradition lacks value.

“Traditional belief, like Shimen’s, gives the moral life direction, depth and meaning,” Koppel says. “Those who abandon such belief often err in taking for granted the virtues that it bolsters.”

The need for that belief seems expressed subtly by the cover art: a small, framed illustration of a tree, full and green, flourishing because of roots so deep they extend below the frame.

***

Neal Gendler is a Minneapolis writer and editor.

 

Related Posts

‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022
Lifestyle

Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

May 11, 2022
Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions
Theater & Performing Arts

Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

May 10, 2022
Searching for a bridge to the past
Books & Literature

Searching for a bridge to the past

May 9, 2022
‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking
Books & Literature

‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

April 24, 2022
Talented cast elevates ‘Two Jews Walk Into a War …’
Theater & Performing Arts

Talented cast elevates ‘Two Jews Walk Into a War …’

April 24, 2022
A musician’s musician
Music

A musician’s musician

March 16, 2022
Next Post
Editorial: A miraculous vaccine — for some

Editorial: A miraculous vaccine — for some

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECENT ARTICLES

‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

May 11, 2022
Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

May 10, 2022
Searching for a bridge to the past

Searching for a bridge to the past

May 9, 2022

Editorial: Three remarkable lives

May 9, 2022
Editorial: Ukrainians flee their homeland

Editorial: Ukrainians flee their homeland

April 24, 2022

About

Since 1912 the AJW has served as an important news resource for the Jewish community. The Jewish World unites the main Jewish communities in St. Paul and Minneapolis, as well as those in Duluth, Rochester and smaller cities, and bridges the divides between the various Jewish religious streams.

Quick Links

  • About the AJW
  • Advertising Information
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Subscription Information
  • Jewish Community Directory

Contact Us

The American Jewish World
3249 Hennepin Ave., Suite 245
Minneapolis, MN 55408

Tel: 612.824.0030 / Fax: 612.823.0753
editor@ajwnews.com

  • Buy JNews
  • Landing Page
  • Documentation
  • Support Forum

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Homepages
    • Home Page 1
  • News
  • Food
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.