• About
  • Support AJW
  • Jewish Community Directory
  • Subscription Information
  • Contact Us
American Jewish World
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    On trumpet, Frank London

    On trumpet, Frank London

    Editorial: In the ghetto

    Editorial: In the ghetto

    Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring

    Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

    A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

    On trumpet, Frank London

    On trumpet, Frank London

    Surviving the hell of death camps

    Surviving the hell of death camps

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse

    Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse

    My time with the Greek Jewish community

    My time with the Greek Jewish community

    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Tracing family roots in Germany

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    On trumpet, Frank London

    On trumpet, Frank London

    Editorial: In the ghetto

    Editorial: In the ghetto

    Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring

    Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

    A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

    On trumpet, Frank London

    On trumpet, Frank London

    Surviving the hell of death camps

    Surviving the hell of death camps

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse

    Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse

    My time with the Greek Jewish community

    My time with the Greek Jewish community

    Tracing family roots in Germany

    Tracing family roots in Germany

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Rabbi Manis Friedman's contribution to Moment magazine sets off a controversy in the blogosphere

American Jewish World by American Jewish World
May 23, 2020
in News
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A reporter from the Forward newspaper in New York City called yesterday with some questions about a short piece of writing by Rabbi Manis Friedman that appeared in the May-June edition of Moment magazine.
The white-bearded Lubavitch rabbi from St. Paul responded, along with rabbis from other Jewish streams, to the question, “How Should Jews Treat Their Arab Neighbors?” The answers generally counseled against demonization and dehumanization of the Arabs, except for Friedman’s response, which began: 

I don’t believe in western morality, i.e. don’t kill civilians or children, don’t destroy holy sites, don’t fight during holiday seasons, don’t bomb cemeteries, don’t shoot until they shoot first because it is immoral.”¨”¨The only way to fight a moral war is the Jewish way: Destroy their holy sites. Kill men, women and children (and cattle).”¨”¨
Over four paragraphs, Friedman, who is the dean of the internationally renowned Bais Chana Women’s Institute in West St. Paul, argued that “the first Israeli prime minister who declares that he will follow the Old Testament will finally bring peace to the Middle East.”

READ ALSO

On trumpet, Frank London

Editorial: In the ghetto

Rabbi Manis Friedman: I don't believe in western morality. (Photo: Mordecai Specktor)Rabbi Manis Friedman: I don’t believe in western morality. (Photo: Mordecai Specktor)

The celebrated author and lecturer from St. Paul continued:

First, the Arabs will stop using children as shields. Second, they will stop taking hostages knowing that we will not be intimidated. Third, with their holy sites destroyed, they will stop believing that G-d is on their side. Result: no civilian casualties, no children in the line of fire, no false sense of righteousness, in fact, no war.

Zero tolerance for stone throwing, for rockets, for kidnapping will mean that the state has achieved sovereignty. Living by Torah values will make us a light unto the nations who suffer defeat because of a disastrous morality of human invention.

The first blog riposte I read was from Josh Nathan-Kazis, who just left his position as editor of New Voices magazine. He quoted the Friedman missive and commented: “When I come across this sort of thing, I wonder at Chabad’s popularity among secular Jewish students. These aren’t just bad politics, they’re insane politics. At what point does the Chabad rabbi tell the prospective Ba’al Teshuva that he thinks that Israel should ‘destroy their holy sites’? Probably not at the first Shabbat dinner, right? Maybe after two Shabbat dinners, a ‘lunch and learn,’ and a Birthright trip through Mayanot?”
There also is a lively discussion of Friedman’s piece on FailedMessiah.com, which is the creation of Scott Rosenberg, a St. Paulite who once was part of the Chabad-Lubavitch faction in the Twin Cities. He is now definitely on the outs with them. Rosenberg wrote the other day:

I heard this exact logic from Manis Friedman himself several times during the the time I was Chabad. I also heard it from many other Chabad rabbis, and the Rebbe himself said something similar just after or during the Six Day War, I think, but had it expunged from the written record of his talks immediately after.

You’ll find the theology familiar — it comes directly from Rabbi Meir Kahane. It’s no surprise that among Kahane’s biggest supporters were Chabad hasidim.

Rabbi Friedman later amended his statement. On the Moment blog he averred that he had answered a “different question.”
I was only slightly surprised to see Friedman’s name on the “Chabad” contribution to the Moment feature. We have talked a number of times over the years; I have written a few stories about him for the Jewish World, usually to publicize a local lecture. Generally, I look askance at the right-wing political views of the Lubavitch rabbis around here. They know that I endorsed Keith Ellison (termed a mamzer — “bastard” in Yiddish — by a local Lubavitch rabbi during a colloquy in my office) for Congress in 2006. He won election and became the first-ever Muslim to serve in the U.S. House. The social and political views of the Hasidim comport more or less with those of the hard-right evangelical Christians — those marching in the Sarah Palin/Rep. Michele Bachmann/Rush Limbaugh column.
However, Debra Nussbaum Cohen, writing on the Forward’s “Bintel Blog,” seemed shocked upon reading Friedman’s stark views on the Arab-Israeli conflict:

I was pleased to see Manis Friedman representing the Chabad point of view in the “Ask the Rabbis” section of the current issue of Moment magazine — that is, until I read what he actually said to the question of how should Jews treat their Arab neighbors?

She continued today:

Reached in Crown Heights this week, where he has come to make a son’s wedding (one of his 14 children), he said that he is being misunderstood: “I’m suggesting that if we changed our policies and didn’t follow the Western value system that there would be no war and nobody would get hurt. That’s what I said,” he told The Sisterhood.

If, as I have learned from Rabbi Friedman and others, a primary goal of the study and observance of Torah is refinement of one’s soul and behavior, then clearly in this case, being Torah observant has failed profoundly.

For a contemporary rabbi — particularly one who holds himself out as a teacher and mentor — to espouse the view that the policy of the Jewish state should be that we “kill men, women and children (and cattle),” is grotesque.

The Lubavitch rabbis present a benign face in the local Jewish schools and shuls, with their hands-on shofar-making and matzo-baking workshops. On the other hand, their theology is of the fundamentalist stripe, and they are far less inclined than, say, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, to give an inch, or a handful of soil, in the Israeli-Palestinian debacle. As I told the Forward yesterday, Rabbi Friedman more or less reflects the Chabad viewpoint. — Mordecai Specktor

Related Posts

On trumpet, Frank London
Music

On trumpet, Frank London

May 19, 2025
Editorial: In the ghetto
Editorial

Editorial: In the ghetto

April 21, 2025
Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring
Visual Arts

Natalie Fine Shapiro’s artworks bring the colors of spring

April 20, 2025
Taking care of little Joel
Books & Literature

Taking care of little Joel

April 20, 2025
Moving Jews beyond Hitler’s reach
Books & Literature

Moving Jews beyond Hitler’s reach

February 17, 2025
Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse
Latin America

Jewish Cubans survive the island’s economic collapse

February 16, 2025
Next Post

Mainstream press reports tiff over Rabbi Manis Friedman's views on fighting war the 'Jewish way'

Comments 0

  1. Jason says:
    16 years ago

    Wow! I personally think this rabbi is a legend, where has he been hiding?
    I think it’s historically clear to all of us, at times when the Israeli govt. didn’t offer the slightest hint of giving any autonomy/land, we had quiet. The story changes once we gave them options.
    I can clearly see how parallel the Rabbis words are to this fact: Don’t show them that you are ready to give in and by all means are you ready to be ruthless -even with your wives and children who YOU put in harms way- and your end result is: no more women and children in harms way!
    So this policy would actually save more innocent lives than not. You are correct that it will not enhance the Palestinian agenda, but it will defiantly save lives and gear the Palestinians to start building inbound.

    Reply
  2. Pingback: American Jewish World » Blog Archive » Mainstream press reports tiff over Rabbi Manis Friedman’s views on fighting war the ‘Jewish way’
  3. yoav says:
    16 years ago

    90 percent of the jews who responded are more into the passivity of christ and buddha then the old testament there up to there neck in heresy . manis is for real !

    Reply
  4. Pingback: American Jewish World » Blog Archive » Moment revisits Rabbi Friedman controversy

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECENT ARTICLES

A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

A wedding in Hebron gets complicated

May 21, 2025
Editorial: Repression in the guise of fighting antisemitism

Editorial: Repression in the guise of fighting antisemitism

May 20, 2025
On trumpet, Frank London

On trumpet, Frank London

May 19, 2025
Editorial: In the ghetto

Editorial: In the ghetto

April 21, 2025
Surviving the hell of death camps

Surviving the hell of death camps

April 20, 2025

About

Since 1912 the AJW has served as an important news resource for the Jewish community. The Jewish World unites the main Jewish communities in St. Paul and Minneapolis, as well as those in Duluth, Rochester and smaller cities, and bridges the divides between the various Jewish religious streams.

Quick Links

  • About the AJW
  • Advertising Information
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Subscription Information
  • Jewish Community Directory

Contact Us

The American Jewish World
3249 Hennepin Ave., Suite 245
Minneapolis, MN 55408

Tel: 612.824.0030 / Fax: 612.823.0753
editor@ajwnews.com

  • Buy JNews
  • Landing Page
  • Documentation
  • Support Forum

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Food
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • About the AJW
  • Jewish Community Directory
  • Support AJW
  • Subscription Information
  • Contact Us

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.