• About
  • Jewish Community Directory
  • Subscription Information
  • Contact Us
American Jewish World
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    From Jerusalem with love and compassion

    From Jerusalem with love and compassion

    Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

    Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    Poems wanted

    Poems wanted

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    Searching for a bridge to the past

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
  • News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia & New Zealand
    • Europe
    • Israel/Mideast
    • Latin America
    • Minnesota
    • US & Canada
    From Jerusalem with love and compassion

    From Jerusalem with love and compassion

    Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

    Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

  • Arts
    • All
    • Blue Box
    • Books & Literature
    • Music
    • Televison & Film
    • Theater & Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    Poems wanted

    Poems wanted

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

    Searching for a bridge to the past

    Searching for a bridge to the past

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Travel & Culture
    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    ‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

    Hey, Kids: The 2021 AJW Hanuka Cover Contest is accepting entries!

  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • AJW Digital Archives
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
Home Arts

‘If I forget you, O Jerusalem’

‘Jerusalem, Jerusalem: How the Ancient City Ignited Our Modern World’, by James Carroll, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 432 pages, $28.

American Jewish World by American Jewish World
May 23, 2020
in Arts, Books & Literature
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Reviewed by NEAL GENDLER

READ ALSO

Poems wanted

Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

James Carroll’s new book is about two Jerusalems — one of streets and walls, one of longing and imagination — but that doesn’t scratch the surface of this compact yet enormous work.

In 317 pages, Jerusalem, Jerusalem explains the development, purpose and history of religion; the growth of Judaism, Christianity and Islam and the disagreements among them; religion’s shaping of Western civilization; the misinterpretations creating Christian hatred of Jews; how each religion’s loss of Jerusalem increased its longing for it; and how all those matters created conflicts that continue.

The result is a fascinating and rare combination of scholarship and reader accessibility. If Jerusalem, Jerusalem sometimes is slow going, it’s not because of Carroll’s writing — many a newspaper would envy such clarity — but because the weight of his information and ideas simply takes time to digest. His 62 pages of notes contain information as interesting as the text, and useful for Jews unfamiliar with the New Testament.

Carroll begins with a history of human development, from hunting to war, calling ritual sacrifice — particularly the “violence of scapegoating sacrifice” — a way to channel and assuage man’s urge to kill. But “God is the opposite of violence.” He says violence is the problem addressed by the Bible, which is the record of Jews’ rejection of violence.

Carroll, a former Catholic priest, is author of the acclaimed Constantine’s Sword, a 500-page indictment of Christian anti-Semitism, which he continues in this volume. He denounces the Christian idea that Jews’ loss of Jerusalem was God’s punishment for not accepting Jesus as messiah. “Jewish dispersal from Jerusalem was a corollary of [Christian] faith,” he says. “The holy city occupied the center of European maps — and imagination — for more than 1,000 years.… But the Jerusalem of this dream [was]… devoid of Jews.”

Muslims, too, considered the city holy — and naturally theirs. Carroll says Jews’ idea of Jerusalem as holy developed during Babylonian exile, and historically, the physical city has been coveted most by the religions that don’t control it.

The Jerusalem of the imagination has shaped much of Western thought for centuries — particularly fueling the American idea; Puritans saw their New World as the creation of a New Jerusalem. The idea has led to more than 20 Jerusalems, 61 Zions, and 127 Salems across the United States.

Britain also latched on. A William Blake poem set to music encouraged a population exhausted by World War I to fight on until “we have built Jerusalem in England’s green and pleasant land.”

After explaining the three religions’ investment in the concept of Jerusalem, Carroll turns to the earthly Jerusalem, laying the most-direct creation of today’s Jewish-Arab conflict at the feet of World War I-era Britain; it made vague promises of sovereignty to its Hejaz allies and also issued the Balfour Declaration. The author deals with the city’s capture in 1917, as a Christmas gift to the war-weary British public and then with the creation of Israel, including the notion of internationalizing Jerusalem. “Rejection of Jewish power over Jerusalem was imbedded in the DNA of Christendom, and therefore, by 1948, of Western civilization,” he says. One could argue that it remains so.

Carroll’s empathy for Jews and respect for Judaism is beyond challenge. But he seems in this last third of the book to be almost tormented, split between understanding and justifying Jews’ need for and right to Israel, while repeatedly criticizing its treatment of Palestinian Arabs. His notes often cite severe critics of Israel.

Very traditional Jews won’t like his suggestion that Jericho fell to a group of monotheistic Canaanites, perhaps assisted by a small group of Hebrews who’d come from Egypt — in effect, minimizing or negating the Exodus story. And indirectly, he dismisses the belief that God dictated the Torah to Moses at Sinai, referring to writers and editors of the Jewish Bible and the New Testament.

Serious thinkers may not buy all of Carroll’s ideas, but his monumental work demands they pay them serious attention.

***

Neal Gendler is a Minneapolis writer and editor.

(American Jewish World, 5.13.11)

Related Posts

Poems wanted
Books & Literature

Poems wanted

June 7, 2022
Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions
Theater & Performing Arts

Tamara Nadel marries Jewish and Hindu dance traditions

May 10, 2022
Searching for a bridge to the past
Books & Literature

Searching for a bridge to the past

May 9, 2022
‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking
Books & Literature

‘Sadie on a Plate’ spans romance, cooking

April 24, 2022
Talented cast elevates ‘Two Jews Walk Into a War …’
Theater & Performing Arts

Talented cast elevates ‘Two Jews Walk Into a War …’

April 24, 2022
A musician’s musician
Music

A musician’s musician

March 16, 2022
Next Post

Guitarist and composer Nadav Remez shines

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECENT ARTICLES

From Jerusalem with love and compassion

From Jerusalem with love and compassion

June 21, 2022
Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

Jewish groups fight for abortion rights in Minnesota

June 21, 2022
Editorial: Elections and Trump’s big lie

Editorial: Elections and Trump’s big lie

June 24, 2022
Poems wanted

Poems wanted

June 7, 2022
‘Honoring Our Graduates’ in May 2022

Once again: Honoring Our Graduates

May 11, 2022

About

Since 1912 the AJW has served as an important news resource for the Jewish community. The Jewish World unites the main Jewish communities in St. Paul and Minneapolis, as well as those in Duluth, Rochester and smaller cities, and bridges the divides between the various Jewish religious streams.

Quick Links

  • About the AJW
  • Advertising Information
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Subscription Information
  • Jewish Community Directory

Contact Us

The American Jewish World
3249 Hennepin Ave., Suite 245
Minneapolis, MN 55408

Tel: 612.824.0030 / Fax: 612.823.0753
editor@ajwnews.com

  • Buy JNews
  • Landing Page
  • Documentation
  • Support Forum

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Homepages
    • Home Page 1
  • News
  • Food
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.